The Backhaul Challenge of Next-generation
Networks
by Gaby Junowicz Director, Business
Development
RAD Data Communications
From
the ‘on the move' businessman picking up his emails to music-lovers
downloading songs to their mobile phones, High Speed Downlink Packet
Access (HSDPA) driven applications are finally reaching public consciousness.
Anyone
who has tried to download content from his or her GPS or UMTS mobile
phone will welcome HSDPA as it offers mobile broadband services at
a much faster speed. With speeds of up to 14.4 Mbps per user, it will
significantly shorten the time it takes to download files onto HSDPA
enabled handsets by as much as 82%.
HSDPA
enabled services will undoubtedly be welcomed by UMTS operators too.
Faster downloads are likely to lead to greater service adoption and
increased usage. It will also allow also them to deliver more services
using existing infrastructure and at a reduced cost.
Although
the scramble for 3G licenses hasn't seen the full-scale adoption of
services that the operators would have hoped, times are changing and
the amount of traffic is expected to grow faster than the average revenue
per user. However, operators are all too aware that such high capacity
performance means increased costs, as it also requires significant
additional bandwidth in order to backhaul traffic. As a result,
operators will soon be forced to look to alternative backhaul solutions
which are not only cost effective and scalable but also don't compromise
the quality of their ‘bread and butter' - voice services.
Today
backhaul, a broad term for the provision of connectivity in the service
provider's core network, accounts for a healthy chunk of operator cost
in building and maintaining a mobile network. In fact, it is one of
the major contributors to the high costs of building and running a
mobile network. On average, transport equipment accounts for 25% of
the costs of private cellular backhaul infrastructure. Transport outlays,
moreover, vary between 40-60% of the total cost of leased lines, with
backhaul contributing 75% of that sum.
Despite
all the benefits that 3G adoption will bring to operators they will
also have to keep a watchful eye on the increased infrastructure requirements
of 3G traffic. Most mobile networks currently rely on SDH/SONET or
ATM data transmission services with dedicated phone connection E1/T1
access lines. While one or two E1/T1 lines might be sufficient to handle
the average number of links connected to 2G base stations, the introduction
of HSDPA may increase this to anywhere between eight and 16 E1/T1s
per 3G cellular site.
This
burden on operators is compounded by the need to support legacy 2G
and 2.5G networks as well as emerging 3G operations. In particular,
there's the cost and suitability of the access platform to handle increased
bandwidth capacity and the complexities of voice and data in a converged
network as operators make the transition from traditional telephone
TDM circuit-switched networks to ATM and, eventually, Gigabit Ethernet,
IP or MPLS packet switched networks.
In
meeting this backhaul challenge, mobile operators are faced with an
array of backhaul technologies and network interface choices. Many
have tended to compartmentalise their infrastructure by building out
parallel networks, using a dedicated transport network for each different
mobile generation. Ultimately however, going down this route offers
neither long-term proficiency or cost-effectiveness and operators would
be better served by looking to integrate diverse traffic streams over
a single backhaul link. Quite simply, what's required is a converged
backhaul access network solution that technologically and economically
delivers on all fronts.
One
familiar method for reducing backhaul costs, traditionally implemented
in high- density segments of the core network, such as the Base Station
Controller (BSC) or the Mobile Switching Centre (MSC), is aggregating
several E1/T1s together and utilising statistical multiplexing to transport
them over STM-1 lines. Aggregation is an essential part of existing
cellular network transport design because it allows for more efficient
use of the transport bandwidth and simplifies network management. Statistical
multiplexing, moreover, is quite appropriate for the new types of data
services that 3G will introduce.
With
the introduction of 3G, the mobile world is evolving into a real multimedia
environment. Instead of simply voice services, a wider range of services
is available to subscribers. This range embraces delay-sensitive and
high quality services like video streaming, which require a reserve
backhaul bandwidth (constant rate) to best effort-type services like
Internet surfing, back office services, mailing, data downloads, etc,
which, by nature, are statistical also in terms of the air interface
and backhaul bandwidth usage. These diversified services allow the
operator to design its transport network so as to maximise efficiency
by employing statistical techniques.
This
new era of 3G and HSDPA services presents additional challenges to
network designers. Aggregation, therefore, which characterises existing
core networks, now has become an essential building block in the radio
access and transport networks. In other words, it's now implemented
even at cell sites.
An
additional test for operators is convergence. Convergence of fixed
and mobile networks will also present a test for operator infrastructures.
Some providers have already announced the convergence of mobile and
fixed line services, such as BT's “21st century programme”, 21CN, and
the branding of France Telecom's internet and TV services as Orange.
The
challenge for network architects is that fixed line and mobile services
such as e-mail or internet surfing should feel the same whether they're
being provided over a WiFi connection or a 3G mobile handset. This
will require a unified transport network, which is likely to be based
on IP technology. Various standards bodies are already looking to a
unified IP-based transport network such as IMS (IP Multimedia Subsystem).
On the other side of the equation, 3GPP, the 3rd Generation Partnership
Project, has defined an “all-IP” approach in all its standards.
Traditionally
mobile networks require a high degree of synchronisation to maintain
a proper service quality because cellular traffic is extremely sensitive
to latency and packet loss. This is achieved by distribution of a common
clock to serve as a point of reference among the numerous base stations
spanning the network. Data (packet based) networks such as IP, however,
are statistical-based by nature and do not provide inherent timing
information whatsoever.
In
a data network problems arise as a result of Packet Loss (PL), when
packets do not arrive at their destination, and Packet Delay Variation
(PDV), when packets arrive with random, unpredictable delay. Anyone
who has used VoIP services will be all too aware of this issue. Sophisticated
clock recovery mechanisms are required to reconstruct timing and achieve
the desired timing accuracy in the presence of packet delay variation
and packet loss. This kind of clock recovery mechanism results in a
process that negates the effect of the random PDV and captures the
average rate of transmission of the original bit stream.
By
applying pseudo wire technologies, mobile operators will be able to
speedily deploy high capacity W-CDMA services and keep HSDPA operating
costs to a minimum while increasing their revenues and profitability
from media-rich 3G content. As an interim solution, those mobile
operators should also consider a hybrid solution that will run all
their existing and delay-sensitive traffic over the deployed TDM links,
while only the aggregation HSDPA traffic will be connected employing
pseudo-wire technologies and packet transport networks.
In
making the vision of 3G enabled networks work, mobile telephony's backhaul
challenge has paved the way for new solutions to be incorporated in
the transport network, such as packet-based technologies. Enablers
of that migration such as pseudo-wire techniques will help to ease
the transition to our 3G futures.
RAD
Data Communications is a leading developer of access solutions for
data and telecommunications.
Author Biography
Mr. Gaby Junowicz joined RAD Data Communications in January 2000 as a Business
Development Manager, and was promoted to Senior Business Development Manager
in 2003 and Director of Business Development in 2005. In this role Mr.
Junowicz is
responsible for the company strategy and business development in the area
of
solutions for cellular and wireless networks.
|