Introduction
It
is reasonably estimated that backhaul accounts for one-fifth of the
overall mobile network cost, and analysts expect this to increase
dramatically – Infonetics estimates that the $16 billion that
carriers spent on mobile backhaul link services in 2005 will double
by 2009. In fact, with the arrival of 3G (and 4G), the requirement
for closer cell site spacing will require even more backhaul, and
it’s related expense. Increased support for data and multimedia
services will also increase typical TDM (T1/E1) connections per site
from 2-4 today to more than 12 in a few years – adding
to the burden of backhaul costs.
In
order to remain competitive, mobile operators must deliver a compelling ‘quad
play’
of voice, video, data and mobility. For many mobile carriers, the highest
service revenue opportunities are in dense city environments, which
often present coverage challenges or deadzones. With the emergence
of microcell and picocell network topologies, the use of mobile networks
to deliver a full suite of broadband services into these urban markets
is no longer constrained by technology limitations, access bandwidth,
or coverage issues. The challenge lies in developing a compelling business
case in which new revenues from broadband services aren’t consumed
by the high cost of backhauling the traffic from an increased number
of cells over T1/E1 leased lines.
Traditional
point-to-point wireless solutions can provide an alternative to leased
line backhaul. But these relatively expensive wireless backhaul approaches
can only be applied to mobile backhaul across predominantly open
areas and even then, they inherently lack resiliency. They are not
effective in dense urban canyons where line of sight limitations
and the need to collocate with mobile basestations dictate a pole-
or building-mounted approach closer to ‘street level’. In
fact, carrier-grade wireless mesh backhaul can address both the opportunities
and challenges inherent in delivering broadband services in dense,
customer-rich urban environments, at about one-fifth of the cost
per link of traditional wireless solutions.
Carrier-grade
switched wireless mesh enables mobile operators to reduce their backhaul
operating costs while achieving the required resiliency and capacity.
These savings enable carriers to cost-effectively increase revenues
through high-value broadband services while optimizing their cell
coverage and controlling costs through re-use of valuable licensed
spectrum.
Macrocell
backhaul
Offering
significant savings the traditional TI/E1 approach, switched wireless
mesh can backhaul multiple macrocells and aggregate the traffic to
a single wired location, as shown in Figure 1. While reducing
the number and associated cost of leased lines, this approach increases
the total capacity available at each cell site. Moreover, eliminating
the need for wired backhaul at each cell location also reduces network
design and installation costs.
With
the capacity to carry both TDM and IP traffic, the solution solves
legacy backhaul costs while accommodating future growth scenarios.

Figure 1: Wireless mesh backhaul
aggregating macrocells to points of wired network connection.
Picocell
Backhaul
One
of the reasons small cells have not been deployed in great numbers
has been the high operating expense (OPEX) and build costs of deploying
fractional TDM circuits. Switched wireless mesh can be used to backhaul
over 50 picocells, or as many as 25 microcells – aggregating
the traffic to a single wired location, as shown in Figure 2.
Operators
now have a practical, cost-effective solution that enables easy deployment
of more microcells and picocells in cities without increasing backhaul
costs.

Figure 2: Switched wireless mesh
backhaul aggregating picocells to a single point of wired network
connection.
Integrated
Circuit Emulation
Integrated
Circuit Emulation Module (CEM) allows connection for up to 4 T1 or
E1 circuits, as shown in Figure 3.
The
CEM takes the TDM bits, including framing and alarms, and ‘packetizes’ them
with a pseudo wire header to a standard format – draft-ietf-pwe3-cesopsn-07.txt.
The packets are time stamped, using RFC3550 RTP, enabling the remote
CEM to recover and regenerate the clock. The result is complete and
seamless emulation of T1/E1 circuits over a low-latency IP connection.
The
BelAir node maintains full T1/E1 bit, byte, frame and alarm continuity,
as well as transporting and recovering clock to 3GPP specifications.
The simultaneous IP and TDM capability provides support for both
legacy and 3G basestations.

Figure 3: BelAir’s Integrated
Circuit Emulation Module carries four T1/E1 lines over IP.
Low
cost unlocks broadband revenues
Whether
supporting picocell, microcell or macrocell deployments, a switched
wireless mesh backhaul can deliver low cost mobile backhaul with
carrier-grade resiliency on a multi-service architecture. In fact,
wireless mesh backhaul delivers significant savings, as shown in
Figure 4, strengthening the business case for new opportunities while
reducing costs to make the existing business more profitable.

Figure 4: Example cost comparison
of BelAir wireless mesh backhaul vs. traditional backhaul for a
cluster of 5 cell sites.
In
the above example, the BelAir switched mesh backhaul solution offers
OPEX savings of 60% per month in year 1. Even when the capitalized
cost of BelAir equipment is factored in, overall cost savings are
nearly 40% year 1 and 50% by year 3.
“This
innovative use of mesh technology is a technical advance that offers
economic benefits for operators who are battling increasing transport
costs. The BelAir solution is the first wireless mesh that delivers
the timing and quality of service required for mobile backhaul across
multiple hops. This mesh approach is attractive as a low cost technique
for facilitating backhaul to micro and picocellular sites.” Philip
Marshall, Vice President, Yankee Group
Benefits
for mobile operators
Improved
reliability
Switched
mesh wireless architecture provides multiple data paths through the
network and offers improved reliability over point-to-point wireless
mesh. In the event of a link failure, traffic is automatically rerouted
to the next best alternative path, ensuring uninterrupted transmission
through a ‘self-healing’ wireless mesh network.
Carrier-grade
performance
Each
radio can transport 6 to 8 T1s for a total throughput of 25 Mbps.
Consequently, a four-radio BelAir200 can transport 100 Mbps or 24
T1s of payload.
The
Circuit Emulation Module (CEM) on the node includes advanced clock
recovery algorithms that meet the timing requirements of the mobile
base transceiver station (BTS). It connects directly to any standard
CDMA, WiMAX, GSM or 3G cells without the need for customization or
network changes
Low
latency
Low
latency is critical for delivering carrier-grade service. The patented
switched mesh architecture discussed offers latency of less than
3 milliseconds per hop on a moderately loaded network, with little
variability.
Quality
of Service
This
switched mesh architecture delivers carrier-grade QoS, enabling Service
Level Agreements. BelAir’s sophisticated routing cores and
radio modules feature advanced QoS tagging and classification capabilities
with multiple queues on the wireless mesh backhaul and wireless access
network, enabling operators to provide preferential bandwidth and
latency characteristics to support voice, along with other traffic
types, end-to-end throughout the network.
Flexibility
This
wireless mesh architecture enables greater design flexibility by
allowing operators to route traffic around obstacles and eliminating
the requirement for line of sight between basestations and wired
locations.
Fast
time to market
Typical
TDM circuits can take up to 90 to 180 days to implement, whereas
wireless mesh circuits can be installed in hours. With wireless mesh
backhaul, operators can take advantage of faster time to market in
new and emerging broadband services opportunities.
Rugged
outdoor equipment
Compact,
easy to install, and built specifically for outdoor deployment, these
carrier-grade nodes can be mounted directly on buildings or light
poles, in parking lots or city streets and are designed to blend
in with the physical infrastructure.
Greater
resiliency
For
macrocell, microcell and picocell deployments, carrier-grade wireless
mesh backhaul provides greater resiliency than point-to-point topologies.